A bright Plymouth living room with an oatmeal armchair and oak table beside a large window overlooking neighboring homes and mostly bare autumn trees.

Choosing Between Plymouth and Plymouth Township in the Year Their Prices Met

Through the first ten months of 2026, the median residential sale price in the City of Plymouth was $572,500. In Plymouth Township it was $577,500. On price alone, a buyer comparing the walkable streets around Kellogg Park with the subdivisions out toward Haggerty and Napier would have trouble telling the two apart this year. The difference showed up in supply. From January through October, the City put fewer homes on the market and they took longer to sell. The Township listed far more homes and sold them faster.

That changes the question for anyone choosing between them this winter. Price alone won't settle it. The more useful questions are which market will have something to show you and how fast you will need to move when it does.

Two Medians, $5,000 Apart

Both figures come from Realcomp's October 2026 Local Market Update for the City of Plymouth and its companion report for Plymouth Township. Both run year-to-date through October and were current as of early November. The City's year-to-date median rose 16.3% from $492,450 over the same stretch of 2025. The Township's rose 9.4% from $528,000. The City has closed most of a gap that stood at more than $35,000 a year earlier.

Sellers on both sides got about what they asked. Through October 2026, City sellers received 101.7% of list price and Township sellers received 101.8%. Through October of this year, a City address did not cost more than the Township.

The single-month numbers make a weaker case. October 2026 alone shows a City median of $830,000 and a Township median of $550,000. That month's City figure rests on nine closings and the Township's on fifteen, and Realcomp notes on the report itself that small samples can make the changes look extreme. The ten-month numbers give the steadier read.

The City Ran Short of Listings

The City's year is mostly a story of fewer homes. New residential listings fell from 208 in January through October 2025 to 151 over the same months of 2026, down 27.4%. Pending sales fell 33.5%, to 109, and closed sales fell to 114 from 148. Prices still rose, but the homes that came up took longer to sell. Median days on market through October 2026 reached 26, up from 20 a year earlier.

City condos followed the same pattern. Year-to-date through October 2026, new condo listings fell 24% to 98, closed sales fell to 62 from 89, and days on market rose from 30 to 50. The condo median rose 7.7% to $398,450.

For a buyer, a smaller and slower City market means two things. First, expect fewer homes to choose from in any given month. At the end of October 2026 the City had 20 residential listings and 19 condo listings. Second, the homes that do come up are getting a little more time on the market than they did in 2025. If you want a specific block near Old Village or Kellogg Park, waiting for the right listing is a real cost. When that house does come up, though, you have a few more days to look at it.

The Township Nearly Doubled Its Supply and Still Sold Faster

Plymouth Township went the other way. Residential new listings rose from 165 in January through October 2025 to 280 over the same months of 2026, up 69.7%. Closed sales rose 46% to 200, and median days on market fell from 24 to 16. Supply rises like that usually soften prices. The Township's median still rose 9.4%, and its homes sold ten days faster than the City's.

Condos made the change easiest to see. Township condo listings went from 71 to 141 over the first ten months of 2026, and the condo median rose 41.7% to $425,950.

Ann Arbor Road near Haggerty is one place to see that new supply. The Towns at Plymouth Walk is a Toll Brothers townhome community at 41700 Ann Arbor Road. In 2024, Hometown Life described it as part of a combined project of 369 apartments and townhouses, with townhome sales expected in early 2025 at prices starting in the mid-$500,000s. In mid-November 2026, Toll Brothers' Plymouth page listed the community from $429,000, with four quick move-in homes. All were three-bedroom townhomes with two-car garages and 1,861 to 2,061 square feet. Base prices for its four floor plans ran from $434,995 for the Howe to $489,995 for the Sanders Elite. The project's developer, Schafer Development, lists 120 attached condominiums and 228 apartment homes at Plymouth Walk, with completion set for 2028.

Two points from that comparison matter to a buyer. The entry price for a new three-bedroom townhome in the Township is now about $100,000 below what was forecast two years ago. It also sits close to the Township's year-to-date condo median. And with the project not due to finish until 2028, new townhome supply on that stretch of Ann Arbor Road is likely to keep coming.

The Township is also lining up smaller detached projects. Olivewood Estate Site Condominium would put 13 single-family homes, at least 10 of them planned as ranches, at the northwest corner of Ann Arbor and McClumpha roads. It was still in rezoning and site plan review in the Township's August 19, 2026 Planning Commission packet. Hidden Enclave, an 11-home proposal on vacant land east of Napier and Powell roads, appears on the Township's current projects page as a cluster housing review. Buyers looking for a ranch may want to keep an eye on Olivewood.

What the City Is Building Toward

The City's next changes are to its downtown streets, plus a few small infill projects.

DTP Forward is the Downtown Development Authority's long-range redesign of the downtown streetscape. The DDA approved the final plan from SmithGroup on June 8, 2026. The DDA's November 2026 newsletter lists the proposed improvements:

  • wider sidewalks
  • added and improved crosswalks
  • a multimodal path on Main Street
  • curbless streets near Kellogg Park
  • replacement street trees
  • 60 to 80 added on-street parking spaces

The newsletter says construction is expected to start on areas of Harvey Street in 2027. The plan's larger pieces carry larger price tags. A September 14, 2026 DDA packet estimated $20 million for the Main Street and Kellogg Park core and $8 million for Ann Arbor Trail and Forest. The newsletter calls grants essential for the larger phases, and in October the DDA approved hiring SmithGroup for grant-writing support. If you're buying on or near Harvey or Wing, expect street work close to home in your first year or two. If you're buying near Main, the bigger changes depend on grant money and will likely come later.

New housing downtown is coming in small numbers. Hometown Life reported in April 2026 that Walters Group had proposed 87 units, an 81-unit apartment building plus six townhouse-style units, at 639 S. Mill Street and 166 E. Ann Arbor Trail. At the time, the proposal was at the concept review stage. On the former Christian Science Church site, Affordability Village describes nine family homes and advertises availability in summer 2027. Even if all of it gets built, it adds a handful of for-sale homes downtown, compared with the Township's year-to-date increase of more than a hundred new residential listings.

Reading the Two Markets This Winter

Put together, the numbers suggest a different plan for each side. In the City, the limit is choice. A buyer who wants the walk to Kellogg Park should set up searches now and be ready to tour as soon as something comes up, because the City added only four new residential listings in October 2026. City homes have been staying on the market a little longer, so once you find the right one, you can usually take a few days to decide.

In the Township, there are more homes to choose from, but they move faster. Township homes that sold from January through October 2026 spent a median of 16 days on the market, and inventory still stood at only 1.8 months of supply at the end of the month. A Township buyer will see more listings and needs to make decisions faster. Condo buyers have one more option: new construction at Plymouth Walk is a real alternative to resale, and since the project runs through 2028, there's no need to rush the first unit you see.

If you're torn between the two, set your budget first. The year-to-date medians show it will go about as far in either place. Then choose based on the house and the setting you want.

If you own in Plymouth and are thinking about selling, which side of this split your home falls on affects your pricing and timing. Start with an instant home valuation, then call REALTORS® Bob and Mike for a pricing plan.

Follow Us On Instagram